It might not come as a surprise, but at the moment the P38 isn’t running particularly well.
That said, I did drive it last summer — well, towards the end of summer — all the way to the Alps. I couldn’t use it earlier in the season because the transfer case and torque converter still needed to be replaced. Once that work was done, I decided to take it on a proper test: a 2,500 km round trip.
Apart from some overheating brakes, the journey was completely uneventful. That trip finally cured me of the infamous “P38 paranoia” and gave me the confidence that I could just hop in and go anywhere.
When Things Went Wrong
That confidence lasted right up until a trip to the Belgian Ardennes.
Halfway down the motorway, I suddenly saw steam coming from both the front and the rear of the car. With my heart in my throat, I was luckily able to pull off at a nearby petrol station.
There, I discovered that the top right radiator hose had come off, dumping all the coolant. I took a moment to regroup, grabbed my tools, bought several bottles of water, refilled the system, and carefully drove home at a very conservative pace.
Once home, I parked the car and wanted absolutely nothing to do with it. I was completely gutted.
Initial Diagnosis
About a week later, I started looking into the problem more seriously. I ordered a combustion leak tester and fluid to check for a possible head gasket failure. The fluid did turn yellow — although it took quite some time, which already raised some questions.
To better observe what was going on, I installed a transparent hose between the top of the radiator and the expansion tank. This allowed me to visually monitor the coolant flow. I noticed bubbles in the line — sometimes steady, sometimes none at all.
The cooling hoses also became slightly stiffer once the system was closed and pressurized. That in itself isn’t abnormal, as long as they don’t become rock-hard.
I then used an Amazon pressure tester and confirmed that the system was losing pressure. Unfortunately, at that stage, I still couldn’t pinpoint exactly where.
Parts Replacement & Escalation
At that point, I started sourcing parts to eliminate potential failure points. I ordered:
-
A new water pump
-
Bypass pipe behind the engine
-
A head gasket
-
New head bolts
-
Additional gaskets
With the BMW M51 diesel, things get tricky. Once the cylinder head is warped, skimming is not recommended, as it can lead to cracks around the swirl chambers.
I always believed new cylinder heads were essentially unobtainable — until I discovered that AMC had just produced a new batch. I didn’t hesitate and ordered one immediately. Even if it turns out not to be strictly necessary, I’m happy to have one available just in case.
Looking Back
If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you may remember that I overhauled the engine about two years ago. At the time, I inspected the cylinder head and already knew it wasn’t fully within specification for longitudinal flatness. If memory serves me right, the limit is 0.10 mm — and mine measured somewhere between 0.10 and 0.15 mm.
According to RAVE, these heads should not be skimmed, so back then I decided to take a calculated risk and reinstall it anyway. That gamble paid off — at least until now.
What’s Next
At this point, I have nearly all the required parts on hand. I’ll continue troubleshooting for a bit longer before fully committing to removing and replacing the cylinder head.
More to come.
By the way some pictures for your enjoyment ✋





